Listing Details for MLS # A4641428
5169 Sandy Shore Avenue, Sarasota, Fl 34242

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Your Phone (required)

    I would like to see MLS Number (required)

    When would you like to see this property?

    Your Message

    Residential Property - Single Family Residence in Sarasota

    Listing Price: $3,500,000Days on Market: 14

    Description of Property

    One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in one of Siesta Key’s most sought-after neighborhoods, this custom-built waterfront home by renowned luxury builder Lee Wetherington is a true architectural masterpiece. With its picturesque Key West-style design, this home seamlessly blends coastal elegance, warmth, and functionality, offering a serene retreat surrounded by lush tropical beauty. From the moment you arrive, two stately oak trees and impeccably maintained landscaping create a welcoming first impression, setting the stage for the stunning interior beyond. Walls of windows flood the home with natural light, framing breathtaking tropical views from every room and enhancing the bright, airy ambiance throughout. Prime Location – Walkable, Bikable, and Boater-Friendly - Situated in a peaceful, walkable neighborhood, this home offers effortless access to Siesta Key Village, where charming boutiques, top-rated dining, and world-famous beaches await. Whether you prefer biking to the Village, strolling along the shore, or boating directly from your private dock, this property delivers the ultimate luxury island lifestyle. Thoughtfully Designed for Comfort & Elegance - Step inside to soaring 12-ft cathedral ceilings, exquisite wood moldings, and an open-concept floor plan that blends sophisticated design with everyday functionality. The newly updated kitchen features Thermador appliances, custom cabinetry, and stunning quartz countertops—perfect for entertaining or casual dining. The first-floor master suite offers a private retreat with spa-like amenities. Two spacious guest suites with en-suite baths provide exceptional comfort and privacy. A dedicated study with tranquil views of the beautiful oak trees is ideal for work or quiet relaxation. Outdoor Living at Its Finest - Designed for effortless entertaining, the heated saltwater pool, spa, and summer kitchen create a private oasis, perfect for hosting guests or unwinding in a peaceful waterfront setting. Boating and fishing enthusiasts will love the private dock and boat lift, providing direct access to the open bay and stunning sunset views. Additional Features: Smart home ready with modern updates throughout. Freshly painted interior with a brand-new HVAC system and hurricane-rated windows. Spacious 3-car garage with built-in storage for specialty vehicles or hobbies. NO HOA FEES in a well-maintained, high-value neighborhood. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a true Siesta Key gem, offering the perfect blend of luxury, convenience, and waterfront serenity.The average asking price for a 3 bedroom/3 bath single family residence in this Zip code is $2,564,036. This single family residence is listed at about 137% of the average asking price. There are 5 3 bedroom/3 bath homes between $3,000,000 and $4,000,000 currently listed for sale in this Zip code. See other listings like this one »

    5169 Sandy Shore Ave., Siesta Key, FL 34242 - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Dual Master Showers - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Walk-In Master Closet - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Walk-In Master Closet - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Laundry by Master Bath - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Spacious Kitchen Island - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Kitchen Island - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    5169 Sandy Shore Ave., Siesta Key, FL 34242 - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Kitchen Island - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Entertaining - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Sliding Glass Doors - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Open Floor Plan - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Light & Air - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Open Concept - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Open Concept - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Dining Area - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Study - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Master Bedroom - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Master Bedroom - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Master Bedroom - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Master Bedroom - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Pool Guest 1/2 Bath - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Stairs from Single Garage to Main Level & Guest Su - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Study Nook - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Guest Room #1 With En Suite - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Guest Room #2 With En Suite - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Guest Room #2 With En Suite - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Outdoor Kitchen - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Salt Spa & Pool - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Landscaping - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Fenced Yard - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Canal Views - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Canal Views - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Front Entry - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Siesta Key - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
    Virtually Staged - MLS #A4641428 - SARASOTA
     

    Property Details At A Glance

    Property Type: Residential
    Property Use or Sub Type: Single Family Residence
    City: Sarasota
    County: Sarasota
    Subdivision: Sara Sands
    Bedrooms: 3
    Bathrooms: 3
    Half Baths: 1
    Sq. Ft. Gross: 4,678
    Sq. Ft. Living Area: 2,885
    Cost per (heated) sqare foot: $1,213
    Year built: 2015
    Annual Tax: $27,601

    Taxes and fees can change periodically, and other fees may apply. Please check with your Suncoasteam agent for more details.

    Interior Features:

    • Built-in Features
    • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
    • Ceiling Fan(s)
    • Crown Molding
    • High Ceilings
    • Open Floorplan
    • Primary Bedroom Main Floor
    • Smart Home
    • Solid Wood Cabinets
    • Stone Counters
    • Vaulted Ceiling(s)
    • Walk-In Closet(s)
    • Wet Bar

    Appliances:

    • Built-In Oven
    • Dishwasher
    • Dryer
    • Freezer
    • Microwave
    • Range
    • Range Hood
    • Refrigerator
    • Tankless Water Heater
    • Washer
    • Water Filtration System
    • Water Softener
    • Wine Refrigerator

    Accessibility Features:

    Window Features:

    • Double Pane Windows
    • Impact Glass/Storm Windows
    • Shades

    Additional Rooms:

    • Attic
    • Den/Library/Office
    • Storage Rooms

    Ceiling Type:
    Flooring: Engineered Hardwood, Tile

    Laundry Features: Laundry Room

    Schools

    Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
    Middle/Junior High School: Brookside Middle
    High School: Sarasota High

    Pool & Waterfront Info

    Private Pool: Yes

    Pool Features:

    • Heated
    • In Ground
    • Lighting
    • Salt Water
    • Self Cleaning
    • Tile

    Spa Features: Heated
    Water Front: Yes
    Water Frontage: Canal - Saltwater
    Water Access: Yes
    Water Access Type: Canal - Saltwater, Intracoastal Waterway
    Water View: Canal

    Water Extras: Lift, Seawall - Concrete

    Exterior & Construction

    Architectural Style:

    • Coastal
    • Florida
    • Key West

    Construction:
    • Concrete
    • Stone
    • Stucco
    • Wood Frame

    Foundation: Stem Wall
    Roof: Metal

    Exterior Features:
    • French Doors
    • Irrigation System
    • Outdoor Kitchen
    • Outdoor Shower
    • Rain Gutters
    • Sliding Doors

    Garage: Yes
    Garage Spaces: 3

    Parking Features:
    • Circular Driveway
    • Garage Door Opener
    • Split Garage
    • Workshop in Garage

    Floors Total:
    Floors in Unit: Two

    Cooling:
    • Central Air
    • Humidity Control
    • Zoned

    Heating & Fuel: Electric, Propane
    Electric:

    Patio & Porch Features:

    • Covered
    • Enclosed
    • Patio
    • Screened

    Security Features: Security System, Smoke Detector(s)
    Other Structures:
    View: Pool, Water
    Fencing: Fenced

    Utilities:

    • Cable Connected
    • Electricity Connected
    • Fiber Optics
    • Sewer Connected
    • Underground Utilities
    • Water Connected

    Sewer: Public Sewer
    Water Source: Public
    Community Features:
    Association Amenities:

    Lot Information

    Lot Features:

    • Cul-De-Sac
    • Flood Zone
    • Landscaped

    Lot Size (acres): 0.31
    Lot Size (sq. ft.): 13,415 square feet
    Road Frontage: Street Paved
    Front Exposure: West
    Adjoining Property:
    Current Adjacent Use:

    Legal Description & Other Information

    Financing Available: Cash, Conventional
    Parcel Number: 0081140027
    Zoning: RSF2
    Tax Legal Desc.: LOT 54 SARA SANDS UNIT 4
    Section: 12
    Range: 17

    Map

     

    Listing courtesy of WATERSIDE REALTY LLC. The information relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

    Or Register (it's free)

    • All lowercase, no spaces, please.
    • Type your password. Minimum length of 8 characters.
      The password must have a minimum strength of Medium
      Strength indicator

      Your Name (required)

      Your Email (required)

      Your Phone (optional)

      MLS Number (required)

      Your Message (required)

        Your Name (required)

        Your Email (required)

        Your Phone (optional)

        MLS Number (required)

        Your Message (required)

        Your Suncoasteam: Southwest Florida Real Estate Specialists
        Suncoasteam logo is a trademark of Jim Mulligan • Log inEdit Profile
        Copyright © 2002-2025 Suncoasteam Realty, LLC. All rights reserved.
        Designed by Tropical Web Works Contact Us »

        Suncoasteam Realty, LLC
        Main Office: 21202 Olean Blvd Unit C-3, Port Charlotte, FL 33952
        Mailing Address: PO Box 380503, Port Charlotte, FL 33938
        Phone: 941-235-7474
        Email: sales@suncoasteam.com
        https://www.sctre.com/details?MLNum=A4641428